Cold-Water Immersion for Recovery: New Insights for Women

For years, cold-water immersion (CWI) has been both praised and questioned in sports science. Is it an effective tool for recovery, or does it suppress key physiological processes necessary for adaptation? While most research has been conducted on men, a recent randomized controlled trial provides much-needed insight into how women respond to CWI after exercise-induced muscle damage.

This newsletter takes a deep dive into the study, the ongoing debate about cold therapy, and the best ways women can use CWI to optimize recovery.

What Did the Study Investigate?

This study aimed to assess the impact of five consecutive days of cold-water immersion (14°C for 15 minutes) following intense hamstring exercises designed to induce muscle damage. Researchers evaluated muscle strength recovery, muscle soreness levels, and biomarkers of muscle damage to determine whether CWI aids in the repair process.

The study is significant because women are often underrepresented in sports science research, leading to uncertainty about whether traditional recovery strategies apply equally to both sexes.

Key Findings

The results of the study highlight several potential benefits of cold-water immersion for female athletes and active individuals:

- Faster Recovery of Muscle Strength – Participants who underwent CWI regained their hamstring strength significantly faster than those who did not, suggesting that CWI may be useful for maintaining performance during periods of heavy training or competition.

- Reduced Muscle Soreness – Those in the CWI group reported noticeably lower levels of muscle soreness, making it easier to continue training without excessive discomfort.

- Lower Biomarkers of Muscle Damage – Blood tests showed that CWI participants had reduced levels of muscle damage indicators, which supports the theory that cold therapy can accelerate the repair process.

These findings make a strong case for the use of CWI in structured recovery strategies for women, especially after sessions involving high-intensity or eccentric loading that induce muscle damage.

The Scientific Debate: Does CWI Hinder Adaptation?

One of the most debated aspects of cold-water immersion is whether it negatively affects long-term muscle adaptation. Some studies suggest that CWI blunts inflammation, which is a natural and necessary process for muscle repair and growth. Since inflammation is part of the muscle adaptation cycle, reducing it too aggressively might interfere with long-term strength and hypertrophy gains.

However, the timing and frequency of CWI matter. The concern about blunting adaptation primarily applies to resistance training aimed at muscle hypertrophy. In contrast, when used strategically—especially after intense workouts that cause muscle breakdown and soreness—CWI can help maintain training consistency and performance without major drawbacks.

This is particularly relevant for women, as hormonal fluctuations can affect muscle recovery, inflammation, and repair mechanisms. Given that most recovery protocols have been studied primarily in men, this research is a step toward developing recovery strategies tailored to female physiology.

When Should Women Use Cold-Water Immersion?

The key takeaway from this study is that CWI is an effective recovery tool when used strategically. Here’s how women can incorporate CWI without compromising long-term adaptation:

✔ After high-intensity training or competitions – CWI can help reduce soreness and enhance recovery, allowing for better performance in subsequent training sessions.

✔ During heavy training cycles – When training volume is high, CWI may aid in faster recovery, helping prevent excessive fatigue and overtraining.

✔ As a tool for injury management – Since the study found reductions in muscle damage markers, CWI could be beneficial for mitigating muscle strain and promoting repair.

Avoid immediately after strength-focused resistance training – If the goal is muscle growth, avoid CWI immediately after workouts designed to build muscle, as reducing inflammation too early might hinder hypertrophy.

Should Women Use CWI for Recovery?

The findings of this study support the idea that CWI is a valuable tool for female athletes and active individuals, particularly for reducing soreness and accelerating strength recovery. While concerns about adaptation remain relevant, when used in the right context—after intense or damaging training rather than after hypertrophy-focused sessions—CWI is a science-backed recovery strategy.

With women being significantly underrepresented in exercise science research, this study is an important step toward tailoring recovery protocols that acknowledge biological differences and improve training outcomes.

My Perspective on Women and Cold Water Immersion

There’s a growing trend around cold plunges—and with good reason. We know from the research that cold exposure activates brown fat, improves metabolic flexibility, sharpens mental focus, and increases stress resilience. But much of the conversation around cold exposure has ignored one key factor: sex differences in metabolic and hormonal responses.

Here’s what I want women to know, from a scientific standpoint:

1. Cold Water Is a Powerful Stressor—That’s the Point

Cold exposure works because it’s uncomfortable. It triggers a controlled stress response—vasoconstriction, a spike in norepinephrine, and a metabolic shift toward heat production (non-shivering thermogenesis). But how women’s bodies respond to that stressor can differ significantly from men’s, depending on cycle phase, hormone status, and body composition.

2. Women May Feel Cold More Intensely—But That Doesn’t Mean It’s Less Effective

Estrogen influences vasodilation and thermoregulation. In practice, this means many women experience cold more acutely, especially during the luteal phase of their menstrual cycle, when core temperature is slightly elevated. That doesn't make the cold plunge “less effective”—but it may change how tolerable or beneficial it feels at certain times.

3. The Science Is Under-Studied—but Promising

Most cold exposure studies to date have focused on men. We need more data on how women uniquely respond—especially regarding metabolism, recovery, and hormonal health. But early research suggests that cold exposure can support mitochondrial health, reduce inflammation, and aid fat oxidation in women just as effectively when appropriately dosed.

4. Adaptation Happens—But Timing Matters

Women may benefit from shorter, more frequent exposures, rather than aggressive plunges that increase cortisol too dramatically. Pay attention to recovery, sleep, and how you feel post-immersion. If your nervous system feels overwhelmed or sleep is disrupted, dial it back.

5. This Is Not About Toughness—It’s About Regulation

Cold immersion isn’t about proving anything. It’s a tool for nervous system regulation, metabolic stimulation, and building resilience. Used with intention, it can be transformative. But more isn’t always better—especially for women navigating hormonal fluctuations, high training loads, or chronic stress.

My Take?
Cold immersion is a metabolic lever—but it needs to be tailored. Women can benefit greatly from it, but the practice should be aligned with biology, not forced through discomfort for the sake of discipline. Start small, stay consistent, and track how your body responds over time.

This is how we shift from hype to true metabolic health—by listening to the science and the individual.

I’ll continue covering the latest scientific research in recovery, metabolism, and performance. If you haven't already, sign up to receive future newsletters below.

Offer our science-backed Thermalist Method in your business

Offer the first science-backed contrast therapy workshop with the Thermalist Method Certification.

Gain exclusive instruction from Dr. Susanna Søberg and her medical team through our self-paced online training, where complex scientific concepts are delivered in an engaging and easily digestible format. Every module is designed for clarity, drawing on expertise from neuroscience, epidemiology, human biology, and molecular biology.

Upon certification, you’ll be equipped to offer the Thermalist Method workshop to your clients—bridging science with practice.

For those ready to lead with expertise and evidence-based knowledge: The Thermalist Method Certification Program.